Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 21

Thread: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

  1. #1
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Posts
    2,019

    Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/23/s...ege-teams.html

    Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 prospects? I am not sure I agree that ACHA schools can compete with top 1/3 of D3 schools. Article sort of explains why the quality of D3 hockey has improved so much over the last few years.
    2009-2010 Last Person Standing winner
    2009-2010 Interlock LPS winner

  2. #2
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Sep 1999
    Location
    Burlington, Vermont,USA
    Posts
    1,298
    Quote Originally Posted by hawk View Post
    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/23/s...ege-teams.html

    Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 prospects? I am not sure I agree that ACHA schools can compete with top 1/3 of D3 schools. Article sort of explains why the quality of D3 hockey has improved so much over the last few years.
    Interesting read ... D-3 does not get much attention or respect but we should not be surprised .
    Advocates for college hockey ... College Hockey Inc. Being the best example ... have worked hard to promote D-1 but ignored D-3 for years.
    Last edited by PuckVoice; 04-20-2019 at 03:13 PM.

  3. #3
    who the hello?
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Alta, Ut.
    Posts
    1,180
    Quote Originally Posted by hawk View Post
    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/23/s...ege-teams.html

    Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 prospects? I am not sure I agree that ACHA schools can compete with top 1/3 of D3 schools. Article sort of explains why the quality of D3 hockey has improved so much over the last few years.
    It is absurd to think that ACHA programs can complete with the top 1/3 of D3 schools. To illustrate, Adrian has one of the top ACHA D1 teams in the country and has won a National championship. Their NCAA team has never won a championship. I have yet to see a player matriculate from that schoolís top club team to the NCAA team.

  4. #4

    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    20904/13677/07677/07621
    Posts
    38,451
    Quote Originally Posted by altazo View Post
    It is absurd to think that ACHA programs can complete with the top 1/3 of D3 schools. To illustrate, Adrian has one of the top ACHA D1 teams in the country and has won a National championship. Their NCAA team has never won a championship. I have yet to see a player matriculate from that schoolís top club team to the NCAA team.
    A top flight ACHA1 team would be competitive in most D3 conferences.

  5. #5
    who the hello?
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Alta, Ut.
    Posts
    1,180
    Quote Originally Posted by joecct View Post
    A top flight ACHA1 team would be competitive in most D3 conferences.
    I donít know. You think Adrianís ACHA team would be competitive in the NCHA? It would seem then, that some of the most impactful players on the ACHA team would end up on the NCAA roster at some point during their college career. To my knowledge that has never happened (correct me if Iím wrong, maybe the #3 goalie on the NCAA team was also on the ACHA roster at some point?)

    Arizona State played a two game series with Eau Claire during their first varsity season. Arizona Stateís roster that season was comprised of basically the top half of their returning roster from their ACHA D1 National championship team and NCAA D1 scholarship freshman recruits. That series ended with two ties and, I believe, Eau Claire winning shootouts both nights. Eau Claire did not qualify for the D3 NCAA tournament that season.

    ACHA teams recruit HS players and kids from the NA3HL. it is rare for a player with real, multi-season NAHL, USHL, AJHL, or BCHL experience to end up on an ACHA roster.
    Last edited by altazo; 04-21-2019 at 10:39 PM.

  6. #6
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    22

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Quote Originally Posted by altazo View Post
    I donít know. You think Adrianís ACHA team would be competitive in the NCHA? It would seem then, that some of the most impactful players on the ACHA team would end up on the NCAA roster at some point during their college career. To my knowledge that has never happened (correct me if Iím wrong, maybe the #3 goalie on the NCAA team was also on the ACHA roster at some point?)

    Arizona State played a two game series with Eau Claire during their first varsity season. Arizona Stateís roster that season was comprised of basically the top half of their returning roster from their ACHA D1 National championship team and NCAA D1 scholarship freshman recruits. That series ended with two ties and, I believe, Eau Claire winning shootouts both nights. Eau Claire did not qualify for the D3 NCAA tournament that season.

    ACHA teams recruit HS players and kids from the NA3HL. it is rare for a player with real, multi-season NAHL, USHL, AJHL, or BCHL experience to end up on an ACHA roster.


    I agree. I know kids that are on ACHA D1 rosters and they would have a hard time making many D3 rosters. Maybe the top 2-3 ACHA D1 teams are good but the quality of play drops off quickly after that.

  7. #7

    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    20904/13677/07677/07621
    Posts
    38,451

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Competitive = .500 in league play

  8. #8
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Somewhere East of the Mississippi
    Posts
    144
    Quote Originally Posted by altazo View Post
    I donít know. You think Adrianís ACHA team would be competitive in the NCHA? It would seem then, that some of the most impactful players on the ACHA team would end up on the NCAA roster at some point during their college career. To my knowledge that has never happened (correct me if Iím wrong, maybe the #3 goalie on the NCAA team was also on the ACHA roster at some point?)

    Arizona State played a two game series with Eau Claire during their first varsity season. Arizona Stateís roster that season was comprised of basically the top half of their returning roster from their ACHA D1 National championship team and NCAA D1 scholarship freshman recruits. That series ended with two ties and, I believe, Eau Claire winning shootouts both nights. Eau Claire did not qualify for the D3 NCAA tournament that season.

    ACHA teams recruit HS players and kids from the NA3HL. it is rare for a player with real, multi-season NAHL, USHL, AJHL, or BCHL experience to end up on an ACHA roster.
    Adrian beat Alabama-Huntsville 4-2 in 2013. Oklahoma, one of the top ACHA teams at the time lost both their games to Alabama-Huntsville.

  9. #9
    Hockey Knight in Boston
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Location
    New Jersey
    Posts
    1,117

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Quote Originally Posted by d3hockey57 View Post
    Adrian beat Alabama-Huntsville 4-2 in 2013. Oklahoma, one of the top ACHA teams at the time lost both their games to Alabama-Huntsville.
    Oswego beat the USNDT in 2014 and then the USNDT beat North Dakota*. So Oswego is better than North Dakota

    *probably happened. not going to look it up. doesn't matter for the point I'm making
    #OneKnight

  10. #10
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Rochester, NY USA
    Posts
    5,749

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Quote Originally Posted by KnightsOfTheRound View Post
    Oswego beat the USNDT in 2014 and then the USNDT beat North Dakota*. So Oswego is better than North Dakota

    *probably happened. not going to look it up. doesn't matter for the point I'm making
    Unfortunately, your point gets a little lost when you learn that the USNDT will suit up "different" teams depending on the competition they are playing. They have a very large roster. The team that played Oswego was most likely significantly different than the team that played North Dakota.
    Russell Jaslow
    [Former] SUNYAC Correspondent
    U.S. College Hockey Online

  11. #11
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    out of NYC and up to Orange County
    Posts
    5,511

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Quote Originally Posted by Russell Jaslow View Post
    Unfortunately, your point gets a little lost when you learn that the USNDT will suit up "different" teams depending on the competition they are playing. They have a very large roster. The team that played Oswego was most likely significantly different than the team that played North Dakota.
    Give Oswego their due that night...USA does suit up different players for different games,butÖ..Matthew Tkachuk...Auston Mathews..Jerramy Bracco...Charles McAvoy...Jordan Greenway...Ryan Donato...Troy tracyÖ and I could go on,they suited up a top team that night for some reason,just to name a few,any sound familiar...Don't be a buzzkill...They did outshot us 33-16,final score 5-3 Oswego,wish we could have played North Dakota that night...ok maybe not

  12. #12
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Rochester, NY USA
    Posts
    5,749

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Quote Originally Posted by bakdraft21 View Post
    Give Oswego their due that night...USA does suit up different players for different games,but…..Matthew Tkachuk...Auston Mathews..Jerramy Bracco...Charles McAvoy...Jordan Greenway...Ryan Donato...Troy tracy… and I could go on,they suited up a top team that night for some reason,just to name a few,any sound familiar...Don't be a buzzkill...They did outshot us 33-16,final score 5-3 Oswego,wish we could have played North Dakota that night...ok maybe not
    Never heard of any of those guys. LOL
    Russell Jaslow
    [Former] SUNYAC Correspondent
    U.S. College Hockey Online

  13. #13
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Oct 2018
    Posts
    22
    Quote Originally Posted by joecct View Post
    A top flight ACHA1 team would be competitive in most D3 conferences.
    They would be cellar dwellers in virtually every conference. They would beat their Morrisvilles, Kings, Chatham, Framingham St. They would get manhandled by the contenders

  14. #14

    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    20904/13677/07677/07621
    Posts
    38,451
    Quote Originally Posted by JSicedog View Post
    They would be cellar dwellers in virtually every conference. They would beat their Morrisvilles, Kings, Chatham, Framingham St. They would get manhandled by the contenders
    hence .500 or so. In the world of college hockey, that's competitive.

  15. #15
    Black Bear since D-2
    Join Date
    Dec 2001
    Location
    Central New York
    Posts
    4,333

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Quote Originally Posted by hawk View Post
    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/23/s...ege-teams.html

    Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 prospects? I am not sure I agree that ACHA schools can compete with top 1/3 of D3 schools. Article sort of explains why the quality of D3 hockey has improved so much over the last few years.
    That was an interesting read. Thanks.

    As someone who watches a lot of hockey on both levels, it's been evident to me for several years now that the talent-gulf has narrowed considerably between D-1 and D-3... As the article mentioned, there are just more good young players out there now than ever before.

    I don't necessarily think that D-1 needs to expand, but I do think that the NHL ought to pay more attention to top-tier D-3 players. I've certainly seen a number of D-3 guys recently who were easily more talented than many D-1 draftees, but still seem to end-up in the ECHL or someplace similar.

  16. #16
    Proud supporter of Osmirwich hockey
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    Northfield, VT
    Posts
    16,413
    Quote Originally Posted by Fishman'81 View Post
    That was an interesting read. Thanks.

    As someone who watches a lot of hockey on both levels, it's been evident to me for several years now that the talent-gulf has narrowed considerably between D-1 and D-3... As the article mentioned, there are just more good young players out there now than ever before.

    I don't necessarily think that D-1 needs to expand, but I do think that the NHL ought to pay more attention to top-tier D-3 players. I've certainly seen a number of D-3 guys recently who were easily more talented than many D-1 draftees, but still seem to end-up in the ECHL or someplace similar.
    Will Pelletier has played two full seasons in the AHL now and has more than held his own at that level.

  17. #17
    Black Bear since D-2
    Join Date
    Dec 2001
    Location
    Central New York
    Posts
    4,333

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Quote Originally Posted by PrezdeJohnson09 View Post
    Will Pelletier has played two full seasons in the AHL now and has more than held his own at that level.
    But D-3 players making it to the the NHL have been rare. Very, very rare.

    Guess we'll see.

  18. #18
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    202

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    We have talking about that night for a few years now, good night in the OZ

  19. #19
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Aug 1999
    Location
    VT
    Posts
    5,568

    Re: Not enough D1 schools to take all D1 rated prospects

    Quote Originally Posted by PrezdeJohnson09 View Post
    Will Pelletier has played two full seasons in the AHL now and has more than held his own at that level.
    Yet Will only made the second team All American (East) his senior year.
    Go 'Wick!

  20. #20
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Plattsburgh, NY
    Posts
    2,917
    Quote Originally Posted by jerrynu26 View Post
    Yet Will only made the second team All American (East) his senior year.
    "I am not looking for the best players Craig, I am looking for the right players"

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •