Brendan Smith capped his 3 year career as a Badger with 52 points in 2010, however, a slow start with only 12 his first season leaves Smitty short of this list with 87 career points.
While Justin Schultz never cracked 50 points in his 3 years as a Badger, he did have 22-47-44 leaving him tied with #53 all time, Dany Heatley. Justin's 113 career points also has him tied with Norm McIntosh for the 8th spot among highest scoring Blueliners to ever play for the Badgers. Justin did college hockey right, surprising many by opting to come back to the Badgers for his Junior year, after which he made the jump with Edmonton and has been in the NHL ever since.
You also are correct in thinking that the remaining 2 players on the list played 4 years for the Badgers. Good job EODS!