PDA

View Full Version : "Pay-to-play" - a blessing in disguise?



Pages : [1] 2 3

Osorojo
10-30-2011, 12:18 PM
The NCAA decision to allow colleges to pay their athletes for playing may have one excellent consequence. Until now an athlete who committed a felony or flunked all the easiest courses their college could offer were punished in one of two ways: suspension from the team or expulsion from the college. Either of these actions made teams less competitive and disappointed loyal fans. Now the NCAA pay-to-play initiative offers a third alternative. Cut the player's salary but leave the player on the team, subject to being called an "amateur athlete" - harsh punishment indeed. After all, cutting salaries is how private business reacts to people who perform poorly, except, of course, CEO's,Executives, Directors, Managers, Chairmen, Bank Presidents, and their immediate relations. Perhaps, like their counterparts in private business, top level athletes could receive bonuses for bad decisions and destructive actions.

komey1
10-30-2011, 02:41 PM
After all, cutting salaries is how private business reacts to people who perform poorly

What private businesses do that? Usually they just fire them.

Osorojo
10-31-2011, 10:54 AM
What private businesses do that? Usually they just fire them.

When the profits of private financial and industrial corporations tanked two or three years ago their executives, directors, etc. received healthy bonuses, often millions of dollars. Don't you remember? It was only a couple of years ago, and the facts were widely reported. What's good for G.M. is good for the country, right? Why not give losing coaches and underperforming star athletes big bonuses?

LynahFan
10-31-2011, 11:44 AM
When the profits of private financial and industrial corporations tanked two or three years ago their executives, directors, etc. received healthy bonuses, often millions of dollars. Don't you remember? It was only a couple of years ago, and the facts were widely reported. What's good for G.M. is good for the country, right? Why not give losing coaches and underperforming star athletes big bonuses?Umm... According to the US Census (http://www.census.gov/govs/state/), state tax revenue for the state of NY (largely funded by income tax on Wall Street bankers/brokers) fell from $147B in 2008 to $92B in 2009 - a 37% drop. If you think bonuses are anywhere near the same level when things go badly as when they go well, you're smoking some powerful stuff.

Split-N
10-31-2011, 12:01 PM
...Until now an athlete who committed a felony or flunked all the easiest courses their college could offer were punished in one of two ways: suspension from the team or expulsion from the college. Either of these actions made teams less competitive and disappointed loyal fans.
Silly me. All these years I've been under the impression that the prime function of colleges and universities was to produce learned ladies and gentlemen who would go forth into the various professions, advance the human condition, and generally make the world a better place. Running a farm system free gratis for the NFL and NBA was never part of it until TV money started corrupting the ivory towers. How could I have been so wrong?

FlagDUDE08
10-31-2011, 12:19 PM
Silly me. All these years I've been under the impression that the prime function of colleges and universities was to produce learned ladies and gentlemen who would go forth into the various professions, advance the human condition, and generally make the world a better place. Running a farm system free gratis for the NFL and NBA was never part of it until TV money started corrupting the ivory towers. How could I have been so wrong?

Free gratis... isn't that redundant? :D

bigblue_dl
10-31-2011, 12:20 PM
I like turtles.

MUhawks628
10-31-2011, 12:24 PM
I’m convinced bear red is part of a CHN conspiracy to sap and impurify all USCHO posters’ precious bodily fluids.

Split-N
10-31-2011, 01:28 PM
Free gratis... isn't that redundant? :D

Not at all. "Gratis" was intended for Ivy League readers; "free" was intended for the rest of us. That way, everybody gets the message. :p

French Rage
10-31-2011, 01:33 PM
I like how the post starts with a bad idea and then switches into what he thought was a witty political statement. It's basically two asinine posts merged with a ****astic segueway.

FlagDUDE08
10-31-2011, 01:37 PM
Not at all. "Gratis" was intended for Ivy League readers; "free" was intended for the rest of us. That way, everybody gets the message. :p

However for those non-ivy leaguers that have an understanding of Latin, it is redundant. :D Had you put one in parentheses, we wouldn't be having this discussion.

FlagDUDE08
10-31-2011, 01:39 PM
I’m convinced bear red is part of a CHN conspiracy to sap and impurify all USCHO posters’ precious bodily fluids.

Dang, my nickname has caught on... gotta come up with a new one... :p

Split-N
10-31-2011, 02:32 PM
However for those non-ivy leaguers that have an understanding of Latin, it is redundant. :D Had you put one in parentheses, we wouldn't be having this discussion.

OK, I'll see your parentheses and raise you a pair of quotation marks. :cool:

Osorojo
10-31-2011, 02:38 PM
Umm... According to the US Census (http://www.census.gov/govs/state/), state tax revenue for the state of NY (largely funded by income tax on Wall Street bankers/brokers) fell from $147B in 2008 to $92B in 2009 - a 37% drop. If you think bonuses are anywhere near the same level when things go badly as when they go well, you're smoking some powerful stuff.

"largely funded?" Pleeezzze! Your Wall Street heroes, both winners and losers, get splendid tax breaks, haven't you heard? If the NCAA wishes to emulate professional sports with a pay-to-play program why stop at trickle-down? Let's go with signing bonuses, seasonal bonuses, and golden parachutes, all unrelated to actual performance. It's called privatizing. BTW: Don't fret about the "bear red" sobriquet. I got that from H.U.A.C.. Several offspring from that committee post on this site and must have been leafing through old hearing transcripts, reminiscing.

FlagDUDE08
10-31-2011, 02:43 PM
"largely funded?" Pleeezzze! Your Wall Street heroes, both winners and losers, get splendid tax breaks, haven't you heard? If the NCAA wishes to emulate professional sports with a pay-to-play program why stop at trickle-down? Let's go with signing bonuses, seasonal bonuses, and golden parachutes, all unrelated to actual performance. It's called privatizing. BTW: Don't fret about the "bear red" sobriquet. I got that from H.U.A.C.. Several offspring from that committee post on this site and must have been leafing through old hearing transcripts, reminiscing.

I've been using that "sobriquet" the most often on here, and I do not belong to any HUAC. I just understand Spanish. ;) (not fluently, but enough to understand your screen name)

Ryecheers
10-31-2011, 02:45 PM
Suppose a player drops out of school in order to turn pro, will he trigger a "golden parachute" ? O so rojo will describe the kind of ink that the universities will be swimming in!

Considering the restrictive definition of "amateur" as applied to hockey players, the idea of turning a full 180 degrees is ludicrous as well as hypocritical.:confused::eek:

MUhawks628
10-31-2011, 02:48 PM
O so rojo will describe the kind of ink that the universities will be swimming in!


Winner!

bigblue_dl
10-31-2011, 02:59 PM
"largely funded?" Pleeezzze! Your Wall Street heroes, both winners and losers, get splendid tax breaks, haven't you heard? If the NCAA wishes to emulate professional sports with a pay-to-play program why stop at trickle-down? Let's go with signing bonuses, seasonal bonuses, and golden parachutes, all unrelated to actual performance. It's called privatizing. BTW: Don't fret about the "bear red" sobriquet. I got that from H.U.A.C.. Several offspring from that committee post on this site and must have been leafing through old hearing transcripts, reminiscing.Can you be more specific? I hate it when posters talk in generalities instead of being specific.

FlagDUDE08
10-31-2011, 04:50 PM
Can you be more specific? I hate it when posters talk in generalities instead of being specific.

Oh no you di''n't... :p:D

davyd83
10-31-2011, 05:15 PM
This will be very interesting. Can the smaller NCHC schools like Duluth and St Cloud afford the $2,000 per kid if voted in by North Dakota, Denver and a couple of the other bigger budget programs in that league? Where do Western, Miami and UNO fit in that scheme? How about CC? This will be very interesting. Do you once again end up with the same split among the bigger and smaller budgets that destroyed the WCHA?