PDA

View Full Version : Worst ecac ref



Pages : [1] 2

rvd5star69
01-27-2013, 11:53 AM
My top 3 kyotra, hicks, feola

sshablak
01-27-2013, 11:56 AM
That's a very difficult Q !! ALL OF THEM ???

FlagDUDE08
01-27-2013, 12:04 PM
That's a very difficult Q !! ALL OF THEM ???

Hey now, some of the newer ones are pretty decent.

QUBobcats70
01-27-2013, 12:08 PM
1. Bryan Hicks
2. Bryan Hicks
3. Bryan Hicks

DrDemento
01-27-2013, 12:12 PM
My All Time List
1-Pierre Belanger
2-Mike Noeth
3-Tim Kotyra(and rising up the standings fast)
4-Any and all of the Murphys

Slap Shot
01-27-2013, 12:19 PM
Since every conference seems to have had a similar thread this year, there's either too much suckage across the board in college or the fans are asking too much. :)

DrDemento
01-27-2013, 01:02 PM
Since every conference seems to have had a similar thread this year, there's either too much suckage across the board in college or the fans are asking too much. :)

I do not think the officials are any worse today than in the past-hence my list including some old timers. What has happened is that because of the instant replays now available and all the broadcasting of games on TV and the web-there is far greater scrutiny. And since we have this board to post all are upset and aggravation-we seem to vent more. Do most of the officials try to do their best each and every time out there? I'm betting they do. But there are some noteworthy names that crop up most frequently as not being in that category. Just my 2

ZYanksRule
01-27-2013, 04:22 PM
Baker needs to be on this list. He was a joke at Quinnipiac a couple weeks ago, and was embarrassing at Cornell on Friday in a national TV game.

FlagDUDE08
01-27-2013, 04:42 PM
Baker needs to be on this list. He was a joke at Quinnipiac a couple weeks ago, and was embarrassing at Cornell on Friday in a national TV game.

I'll second that. I'm STILL steamed about a five minute fighting major from five years ago where a fight wasn't even involved. Ironically enough, it was a Union game AGAIN.

kdiff77
01-27-2013, 04:50 PM
My top three:

1. MacDonald.
2. All of them.
3. Seriously, they all suck.

Ralph Baer
01-27-2013, 05:05 PM
I do not think the officials are any worse today than in the past-hence my list including some old timers. What has happened is that because of the instant replays now available and all the broadcasting of games on TV and the web-there is far greater scrutiny. And since we have this board to post all are upset and aggravation-we seem to vent more. Do most of the officials try to do their best each and every time out there? I'm betting they do. But there are some noteworthy names that crop up most frequently as not being in that category. Just my 2 I agree with you that they aren't worse than years ago, just that we have more opportunity to watch and complain.

BTW, let's not forget the game that we call Fulton's Folly, although Mr. Fulton disappeared soon after. :)

Somehow, I have managed to expunge the details from my memory bank. :eek:

DrDemento
01-27-2013, 05:27 PM
I agree with you that they aren't worse than years ago, just that we have more opportunity to watch and complain.

BTW, let's not forget the game that we call Fulton's Folly, although Mr. Fulton disappeared soon after. :)

Somehow, I have managed to expunge the deatils from my memory bank. :eek:

Ralph: I remember that episode well. I avoided listing the officials who called one bad game or made a couple bad calls. I tried to limit myself to the ones who most frequently caused stress and upset for me. I also tried to limit myself to those that I personally saw often enough.

jericho
01-27-2013, 06:41 PM
I'll second that. I'm STILL steamed about a five minute fighting major from five years ago where a fight wasn't even involved. Ironically enough, it was a Union game AGAIN.

That explains ALOT.

rvd5star69
01-28-2013, 04:19 PM
1. Bryan Hicks
2. Bryan Hicks
3. Bryan Hicks

Lol

Red Cloud
01-28-2013, 04:38 PM
Bryan Hicks is a joke of a referee. Tim Kotyra should have been run out of the league years ago.

Both of them should probably be shot into the sun.

Havasu M
01-28-2013, 04:43 PM
Bryan Hicks is a joke of a referee. Tim Kotyra should have been run out of the league years ago.

Both of them should probably be shot into the sun.
Now why would you do that to the sun? Maybe a black hole.

theprofromdover
01-28-2013, 05:46 PM
Pete Torgerson should be on this list.

FlagDUDE08
01-28-2013, 05:48 PM
Pete Torgerson should be on this list.

Although he isn't on my list of best refs, I don't think I'd put him on this one. He isn't THAT bad. Maybe a moment or two, but otherwise fairly consistent.

DrDemento
01-28-2013, 08:50 PM
Bryan Hicks is a joke of a referee. Tim Kotyra should have been run out of the league years ago.

Both of them should probably be shot into the sun.

I just have not seen enough of Hicks to know-what i have seen has been bad. Kotyra? i have been following how he officiates our games for a long time-and running him out of the league is actually being too kind.:eek:

engineerhockeyfan
01-29-2013, 10:20 AM
Although he isn't on my list of best refs, I don't think I'd put him on this one. He isn't THAT bad. Maybe a moment or two, but otherwise fairly consistent.

They are all fairly consistent. Some consistently fair, and some consistently awful.
As for me, I will chose the three awful candidates.
Noeth,
Kotyra
Hicks
JMO
Having said that, my biggest problem with all hockey refereeing is the inconsistency of the two officials doing a game.
You can all but commit murder at one end of the ice and the official there will let it go, and you go down to the other end, and a player looks like he might commit an infraction and that official sends him off for what he is thinking.
I would at least like to see both referees doing a game on the same page.