Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

    Although I tend to appreciate Gopher hockey from the perspectives that mariucci and happy hold, tradition is not my issue with this thread. FS23 is doing this for fun and, I think, is trying to get folks involved in some actual hockey discussion, rather than the tedious, neanderthal-like flame wars that typify this forum. For that, I congratulate he and the others who support this thread.

    That said, I don't see tradition as the issue with this ranking. In my mind, tradition is a qualitative measure that simply doesn't work with a quantitatively derived ranking process, such as FS23 used, which is both its strength and its weakness. To me, a more fundamental flaw of the ranking is the time span. It doesn't make sense to me to compare championship teams from the 50's and 60's with those of the past few decades just because they took place under the auspices of the NCAA, anymore than it makes sense to compare an AAU championship with an NCAA championship.

    Of course, the UofMI, MTU and DU, for instance, will hotly dispute my point for obvious reasons. But think about it...the game was far different in the 50's and 60's than it was over the last 20. I know, I played during the 60's. Back then, there were far fewer elite level players and they played fewer games with inferior equipment and facilities. The average level of coaching was also inferior at the college level, considering experience, tactics and motivational skills. The game changed radically after the Soviets began to dominate international play and a number of college coaches had the foresight to adopt Soviet tactics, while the NHL lagged behind holding desperately onto "old-time hockey." Since then, cycling, puck control and transition attack have become nearly standard practices at all levels. Consequently, it takes a team with considerably deeper talent and expert coaching to win a championship today than was the case in the earlier decades of the NCAA. That's not to say the earlier championships don't count, or that they should be downgraded somehow.

    One could sort of normalize for this issue by constricting the time spans into decades or two each. But that would defeat the purpose of the ranking, which I believe is basically about bragging rights, so why bother? I'm simply saying there are too many unmeasurable variables, each with unintended consequences, for this type of ranking to have credibility for anything other than bragging rights on the quantitative success of a program.
    Last edited by HiStick; 01-16-2012, 11:12 AM.

    Comment


    • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

      Originally posted by HiStick View Post
      Although I tend to appreciate Gopher hockey from the perspectives that mariucci and happy hold, tradition is not my issue with this thread. FS23 is doing this for fun and, I think, is trying to get folks involved in some actual hockey discussion, rather than the tedious, neanderthal-like flame wars that typify this forum. For that, I congratulate he and the others who support this thread.

      That said, I don't see tradition as the issue with this ranking. In my mind, tradition is a qualitative measure that simply doesn't work with a quantitatively derived ranking process, such as FS23 used, which is both its strength and its weakness. To me, a more fundamental flaw of the ranking is the time span. It doesn't make sense to me to compare championship teams from the 50's and 60's with those of the past few decades just because they took place under the auspices of the NCAA, anymore than it makes sense to compare an AAU championship with an NCAA championship.

      Of course, the UofMI, MTU and DU, for instance, will hotly dispute my point for obvious reasons. But think about it...the game was far different in the 50's and 60's than it was over the last 20. I know, I played during the 60's. Back then, there were far fewer elite level players and they played fewer games with inferior equipment and facilities. The average level of coaching was also inferior at the college level, considering experience, tactics and motivational skills. The game changed radically after the Soviets began to dominate international play and a number of college coaches had the foresight to adopt Soviet tactics, while the NHL lagged behind holding desperately onto "old-time hockey." Since then, cycling, puck control and transition attack have become nearly standard practices at all levels. Consequently, it takes a team with considerably deeper talent and expert coaching to win a championship today than was the case in the earlier decades of the NCAA. That's not to say the earlier championships don't count, or that they should be downgraded somehow.

      One could sort of normalize for this issue by constricting the time spans into decades or two each. But that would defeat the purpose of the ranking, which I believe is basically about bragging rights, so why bother? I'm simply saying there are too many unmeasurable variables, each with unintended consequences, for this type of ranking to have credibility for anything other than bragging rights on the quantitative success of a program.
      I have to disagree with one of your statements. It was just as hard to win a championship 50 years ago as today. You said "it takes a team with considerably deeper talent and expert coaching to win a championship today than was the case in the earlier decades of the NCAA." I say bull to that. It is different, sure, but only one team won back then, and only one team wins today.
      XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXX


      The reason for the talent in the west? Because MN didn't rely on Canada.

      Originally posted by MN Pond Hockey
      Menards could have sold a lot of rope

      this morning in Grand Forks if North Dakota had trees.

      Comment


      • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

        Originally posted by Fighting Sioux 23 View Post
        Sorry. I knew you would not be too pleased, but it is important to note that being #9 out of thousands of teams is very impressive.
        True, but like I said earlier, I don't think you put enough weight on the trifecta of Regular Season Champion, Conference Tournament Champion and NCAA Champion.
        Michigan Tech Legend, Founder of Mitch's Misfits, Co-Founder of Tech Hockey Guide, and Creator/Host of the Chasing MacNaughton Podcast covering MTU Hockey and the WCHA.

        Sports Allegiance: NFL: GB MLB: MIL NHL: MIN CB: UW CF: UW CH: MTU FIFA: USA MLS: MIN EPL: Everton

        Comment


        • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

          Originally posted by FreshFish View Post
          Ralph, did you enter the contest? If not, who would be YOUR top five teams?
          No I didn't. I was too lazy. The three that come to mind are Maine in 1993, Cornell in 1970, and RPI in 1985. The others would take research.
          sigpic

          Let's Go 'Tute!

          Maxed out at 2,147,483,647 at 10:00 AM EDT 9/17/07.

          2012 Poser Of The Year

          Comment


          • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

            Originally posted by Happy View Post
            I have to disagree with one of your statements. It was just as hard to win a championship 50 years ago as today. You said "it takes a team with considerably deeper talent and expert coaching to win a championship today than was the case in the earlier decades of the NCAA." I say bull to that. It is different, sure, but only one team won back then, and only one team wins today.
            The more teams there are, the harder it is. If there is only one team, it is quite easy. Clearly there are some teams with virtually no chance of winning, but that has always been the case. Actually, 50 years ago in 1962, there were more teams with no chance since the ECAC had not broken up into ECAC-I and ECAC-II yet.
            sigpic

            Let's Go 'Tute!

            Maxed out at 2,147,483,647 at 10:00 AM EDT 9/17/07.

            2012 Poser Of The Year

            Comment


            • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

              Originally posted by Happy View Post
              It is different, sure, but only one team won back then, and only one team wins today.
              Naturally. And that's a valid argument that any national championship, regardless of auspices, is equally meaningful. But that's not my point. I'm saying it's not all relative, as you seem to be suggesting. If it were, then you ought to be willing to accept a rival fan's taunt that 7>5 without any objections about recruiting differences since that's a value judgment that can't be objectively measured.

              The rankings in this thread are based on numbers, thoughtfully done to be sure, but nonetheless one-dimensional. I simply don't agree that teams of vastly different eras, qualitatively, can be meaningfully compared to allow one to formulate the "top" teams of the entire NCAA period, anymore than one can meaningfully rank order the best player of all time based on something like points per game. It's fun to consider, but ultimately means nothing, especially given the contentious crowd that frequents this forum.

              Comment


              • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                Originally posted by Shirtless Guy View Post
                True, but like I said earlier, I don't think you put enough weight on the trifecta of Regular Season Champion, Conference Tournament Champion and NCAA Champion.
                Perhaps. What hurt this Tech squad the most was that the WCHA was not quite as strong in 1961-1962 as in surrounding seasons. If this Tech squad had put up identical numbers in either the season before or after, they would have been a notch or two higher. Obviously there was nothing that Tech could do about that, but a part of the formula deals with conference strength. That, and having a losing record to the other WCHA team in the Final Four, prevented Tech from being a top 5 team.
                North Dakota
                National Champions: 1959, 1963, 1980, 1982, 1987, 1997, 2000, 2016

                Comment


                • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                  Originally posted by Ralph Baer View Post
                  No I didn't. I was too lazy. The three that come to mind are Maine in 1993, Cornell in 1970, and RPI in 1985. The others would take research.
                  Just out of curiosity, how do you stack RPI 1984 vs. the 1985 team, aside from the obvious fact that one team won the NC, the other didn't? Wasn't the 1985 team pretty much the same as its predecessor?
                  if you walk with Jesus, he's gonna save your soul, you gotta keep the devil way down in the hole

                  Comment


                  • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                    Originally posted by HiStick View Post
                    Naturally. And that's a valid argument that any national championship, regardless of auspices, is equally meaningful. But that's not my point. I'm saying it's not all relative, as you seem to be suggesting. If it were, then you ought to be willing to accept a rival fan's taunt that 7>5 without any objections about recruiting differences since that's a value judgment that can't be objectively measured.

                    The rankings in this thread are based on numbers, thoughtfully done to be sure, but nonetheless one-dimensional. I simply don't agree that teams of vastly different eras, qualitatively, can be meaningfully compared to allow one to formulate the "top" teams of the entire NCAA period, anymore than one can meaningfully rank order the best player of all time based on something like points per game. It's fun to consider, but ultimately means nothing, especially given the contentious crowd that frequents this forum.
                    I see that you are relatively new around here, so I will point out that I had a previous thread using this same formula and ranked teams within their era. I was then approached by CHW about doing a list for all the teams, and ultimately decided to tweak the formula as best I could so that teams from different eras could compete on a somewhat neutral playing field. Ultimately, I tend to agree with your vantage point. When this list is done, there are going to be a few more interesting lists and threads done through CHW that should be of more interest to those that like to see comparisons of like eras. Hopefully the site is still around for those to be done.
                    North Dakota
                    National Champions: 1959, 1963, 1980, 1982, 1987, 1997, 2000, 2016

                    Comment


                    • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                      Originally posted by buoldtimer View Post
                      Just out of curiosity, how do you stack RPI 1984 vs. the 1985 team, aside from the obvious fact that one team won the NC, the other didn't? Wasn't the 1985 team pretty much the same as its predecessor?
                      They were pretty much the same team. The 1984 team had better players than 1985 mainly because Marty Dallman '84 was better than any of the incoming players, but the experience gained in 1984 greatly helped the 1985 team. Of the 18 skaters and 3 goalies who dressed in the 1985 championship game, all but transfer John Tiano and freshman Mo Mansi were on the team the previous year, although I think that a couple of others didn't dress when RPI lost to North Dakota in 1984.
                      sigpic

                      Let's Go 'Tute!

                      Maxed out at 2,147,483,647 at 10:00 AM EDT 9/17/07.

                      2012 Poser Of The Year

                      Comment


                      • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                        Originally posted by Ralph Baer View Post
                        No I didn't. I was too lazy. The three that come to mind are Maine in 1993, Cornell in 1970, and RPI in 1985. The others would take research.
                        I had those teams plus Denver '60-'61 as the four teams that seemed to me to be the most likely to be in the top five. We'll see how it plays out.
                        "Hope is a good thing; maybe the best of things."

                        "Beer is a sign that God loves us and wants us to be happy." -- Benjamin Franklin

                        "Being Irish, he had an abiding sense of tragedy, which sustained him through temporary periods of joy." -- W. B. Yeats

                        "People generally are most impatient with those flaws in others about which they are most ashamed of in themselves." - folk wisdom

                        Comment


                        • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                          From time to time, will you provide the point totals generated by your formula? I have them for # 11 - # 25. No need to do it now, at the end would be sufficient, although I would be curious if you posted it for # 6 - # 10 and then for each of the top five as they are released.

                          BTW, on a somewhat-related matter, the distribution of teams across 'eras' (so far) is roughly the same as the distribution of overall championships won during each 'era', which could indicate that your adjustment to your formula to equalize across eras is working (assuming that greatest teams would be equally distributed across eras).

                          45% of championships were won in the "four team" era while 47% of the greatest teams so far were from the "four team" era. 23% of championships were won in the "twelve team" era and 23% of the greatest teams so far are from that era, and 14% of championships were won in the "sixteen team" era and 17% of the greatest teams so far are from that era. Given that we are only looking at 17 teams so far, that is amazingly close correspondence.

                          We'll see how it works out in the end...my 'gut feeling' told me that the sixteen-team era would be slightly overweighted, and so far this is not quite the case.
                          "Hope is a good thing; maybe the best of things."

                          "Beer is a sign that God loves us and wants us to be happy." -- Benjamin Franklin

                          "Being Irish, he had an abiding sense of tragedy, which sustained him through temporary periods of joy." -- W. B. Yeats

                          "People generally are most impatient with those flaws in others about which they are most ashamed of in themselves." - folk wisdom

                          Comment


                          • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                            Originally posted by Fighting Sioux 23 View Post
                            I had a previous thread using this same formula and ranked teams within their era
                            That thread doesn't seem to be available any more.....
                            "Hope is a good thing; maybe the best of things."

                            "Beer is a sign that God loves us and wants us to be happy." -- Benjamin Franklin

                            "Being Irish, he had an abiding sense of tragedy, which sustained him through temporary periods of joy." -- W. B. Yeats

                            "People generally are most impatient with those flaws in others about which they are most ashamed of in themselves." - folk wisdom

                            Comment


                            • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                              Originally posted by FreshFish View Post
                              That thread doesn't seem to be available any more.....
                              Correct. Apparently it was sacrificed when USCHO cut all threads that were 2+ years old (or perhaps that hadn't been posted on in 2+ years).

                              Of course, that thread was done "pre-tweak", so its results would not be exactly the same.
                              North Dakota
                              National Champions: 1959, 1963, 1980, 1982, 1987, 1997, 2000, 2016

                              Comment


                              • Re: The Top 25 College Hockey Teams of the NCAA Era

                                Originally posted by FreshFish View Post
                                From time to time, will you provide the point totals generated by your formula? I have them for # 11 - # 25. No need to do it now, at the end would be sufficient, although I would be curious if you posted it for # 6 - # 10 and then for each of the top five as they are released.

                                BTW, on a somewhat-related matter, the distribution of teams across 'eras' (so far) is roughly the same as the distribution of overall championships won during each 'era', which could indicate that your adjustment to your formula to equalize across eras is working (assuming that greatest teams would be equally distributed across eras).

                                45% of championships were won in the "four team" era while 47% of the greatest teams so far were from the "four team" era. 23% of championships were won in the "twelve team" era and 23% of the greatest teams so far are from that era, and 14% of championships were won in the "sixteen team" era and 17% of the greatest teams so far are from that era. Given that we are only looking at 17 teams so far, that is amazingly close correspondence.

                                We'll see how it works out in the end...my 'gut feeling' told me that the sixteen-team era would be slightly overweighted, and so far this is not quite the case.
                                Interesting. I had no intention of it coming out that way, but I'm glad it has. We'll see how it shakes out at the end.

                                Also, it looks as though it will be #8 this weekend, and at some point there will be a double-release. Sunday looks like the day that they will be posted, so there will not be a mid-week release. Right now the options being discussed are to do #4 and #3 in one week and then #2 and #1 in the final week, or release them one at a time, and then release #3, #2, and #1 for the finale. I like the first option, but we'll see what happens.
                                North Dakota
                                National Champions: 1959, 1963, 1980, 1982, 1987, 1997, 2000, 2016

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X