Should Edgar Martinez be voted into the Hall of Fame?

[scheids316]

Yes or No?

[unofan]

Fact is even if most people think he should, it requires a super majority to get in. I think 75% of voters.

I wouldn't vote for him, and I doubt enough BBWA members will either.

[Bruce Ciskie]

No.

He's a one-dimensional player whose numbers in that one dimension of the game just aren't good enough.

Helluva guy. Helluva player. Not a HOFer.